Svenska Mahjongförbundet : Forum
https://www.svenskmahjong.se/forum/

Some mistakes
https://www.svenskmahjong.se/forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=324
Page 1 of 1

Author:  Lasker [ Sun Oct 18, 2009 10:26 pm ]
Post subject:  Some mistakes

First of all:
Your program is fantastic and very helpful. I have learned so much about Mahjong hands and their scoring.

But some mistakes you should remove:
.) Since two weeks the program did often not generate hands with bamboo 2, because the site http://mahjonghand.appspot.com/images/b2.png could not be loaded, like your example 3:
m 234b 234d h 567b567dDg w gD self_draw

.) h b789 c9 m DwDwDw DrDrDrDr WsWsWs w c9
(here 4 points for Outside Hand are missing)

.) m b789 h c234 d67 b222 DwDw w d5
(Chicken Hand is scoring only 8 points not 12)

.) m c999 b789 WnWnWn h d46 DgDg rw Wn w d5
(here 1 point is missing for Pung of Terminals: c999)

.) m c78c9 h b333 c555 d88 DwDw w d8
There are only Two Concealed Pungs! The third Pung, melded with Hu, counts as Melded Pung, so Mr. Otto Myslivec from Mahjong Club Baden said (he reached the 2. place by the GMO 2009 and he is Staatsmeister 2009 from Austria; it is also the meaning from other strong Austrian Mahjong players).

.) m DwDwDw WwWwWw h d999 d88 c67 w c8 rw Ww sw Ww
Here a Double Pung is shown, but DwDwDw, WwWwWw are no "Double Pungs"

But I repeat it: You have made a good and helpful program for all Mahjong players!

Author:  Fliptop [ Wed Dec 01, 2010 3:39 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Some mistakes

thanks for those information.

i thought they are natural at first but since you said that.

i agree those are mistakes.

Author:  clairebrett [ Fri Jul 15, 2011 12:24 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Some mistakes

I entered the following to the calculator

h d7d8d9b6b6b6b6b9b9b9d5d5DwDw w Dw

and I keep getting the answer that there is an error, that with a kong there should be 14 tiles plus one extra.

Problem is that my hand above does have 14 tiles plus one extra.

Can someone explain where I am going wrong please

Author:  Dick-mt [ Sun Dec 30, 2012 1:04 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Some mistakes

to clairebrett

If the 6-Bamboo kong is concealed, then enter
c b6666 h d789 b999 d55 Dww w Dw
but if that kong is melded, then use
m b6666 h d789 b999 d55 Dww w Dw
In either case, the kong is not actually "in" your hand (h).

Note: in both cases, this calculator makes the mistake of counting as concealed a pung completed by claiming a discard. (Lasker's Oct-2009 message has a bug-report about a similar item.)

Author:  Flb37 [ Mon Jan 21, 2013 5:49 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Some mistakes

Good morning,
I think there is an error in the counting of this hand :

http://mahjonghand.appspot.com/?sit=h+2 ... =Calculate

:dg: :dg: :b2: :b2: :b3: :b3: :b4: :b4: :b6: :b6: :b6: :b6: :b8: :b6r:

When we have : 'All Green ' + Even 'Seven ', it implicates: 'Tile Hog '
we should not therefore count : 'Tile Hog '

Donc 122 et non 124 points
Bonne journée

Author:  Flb37 [ Sat Apr 20, 2013 9:13 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Some mistakes

Good morning,
I think there is an error in the counting of this hand :
http://mahjonghand.appspot.com/?sit=m+4 ... =Calculate
:b4: :b4: :b4: :b6: :b6: :b6: :b2: :b2: :b2r: : :b3: :b3: :b3: :b8: :b8:
The fan 'Two Concealed Pungs' should not count
Total points : 144 and not 146

Author:  Flb37 [ Sat Sep 24, 2016 3:41 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Some mistakes

Bonjour,
Il y a une erreur ici :

:b8: :b8: :b8r: :b6: :b6: :b6: :b6r: :b4: :b4: :b4: :b4: :dg: :dg: :b2: :b2: :b2r:

http://mahjonghand.appspot.com/?sit=m+8 ... =Calculate

One should not count :
"All Even Pungs" : the pair is DgDg and not 2k2k

We must Count :
"All Green"
"All Pungs"
"Half Flush"
"Two Melded Kongs"
"Concealed Kong"

: 88+6+6+4+2=106 points

Thank you for the correction of the error

FLB37

Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC + 1 hour [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/